L2/07-016

Approved Motions of UTC 110 / L2 207 Joint Meeting
Mountain View, CA -- February 5-8, 2007
Hosted by Microsoft
UTC #110 Agenda
November 12, 2007

[110-C1] Consensus: Approve the minutes of UTC 109/L2 207 Joint Meeting. [L2/06-324R2]
[110-C2] Consensus: Change the script property of U+327E: CIRCLED HANGUL IEUNG U to "Hangul". [L2/06-399]

[110-A2] Action Item for Mark Davis: Make the change to Scripts.txt for changing U+327E to have "Hangul" script property. [L2/06-399]

[110-C3] Consensus: Change the script property for all the characters in L2/06-399 with Katakana parts to "Katakana" script, and highlight this in the Unicode 5.0.1 beta to draw attention to the changes.

[110-C4] Consensus: Open a Public Review Issue (PRI) on the desirability of further changes to the script property of the characters in the U+3200 and U+3300 blocks. The wording of the PRI will point out what has been changed and what may be open for review. [L2/06-399]

[110-C5] Consensus: Add regexes from Table 2 of document L2/07-026R2, as revised in discussion, to UCD.html as test patterns, after review by the Editorial Committee.

[110-C6] Consensus: Document the default values for the properties (string and catalog values) as in table 2 of L2/07-026R2, as amended in discussion.

[110-C7] Consensus: Document the way that booleans are represented in the data files for both True and False values, using N and Y instead of F and T in those cases where specific values are called out. [L2/07-026R2]

[110-C8] Consensus: Document in UCD.html and in the text of V 5.0.1 that the algorithmic decomposition mapping values for Hangul syllables are not the full ones but the pair-wise ones. [L2/07-026R2]

[110-C9] Consensus: The UTC is willing to add a new Unicode property for use in IDN with contents of that property determined by rules established by the IETF.

[110-C10] Consensus: Correct Unicode Standard Annex #24: Script Names to say that "Script = unknown" value includes surrogates. [L2/07-026R]

[110-C11] Consensus: Make changes to "blk" and "dt" values in PropertyValueAliases.txt, as in items 8 and 9 of document L2/07-026R without the notes.

[110-C12] Consensus: Document in UCD.html what happens when an explicit value is not provided for the foldings and mappings listed in item #10 of document L2/07-026R, except for special casing conditions.

[110-C13] Consensus: Add a new field to derived numerical values with the rational format for the number. [L2/07-026R]

[110-C14] Consensus: Remove special casing conditions from PropertyValueAliases.txt and UCD.html. Comment in CaseFolding.txt and SpecialCasing.txt that the lines included in item #13 of document L2/07-026R constitutes conditional casing data and do not constitute a formal Unicode property.

[110-C15] Consensus: Change the linebreak property for U+1FFD GREEK OXIA from AL to BB. [L2/07-028]

[110-C16] Consensus: Approve the linebreak changes for 7 characters as documented in [L2/07-050].

[110-C17] Consensus: Accept the change in L2/07-028 for linebreak rule 12B with the addition of ", HY" to the rule. [L2/07-028]

[110-C18] Consensus: Issue a Proposed Update Unicode Standard Annex #14: Line Breaking Properties. [L2/07-028]

[110-C19] Consensus: Add U+00B7 MIDDLE DOT to ID_Continue. [L2/07-033 L2/07-042]

[110-C20] Consensus: Authorize a beta for Unicode 5.0.1.

[110-C21] Consensus: Document in Unicode Standard Annex #31: Identifier and Pattern Syntax that people may want to tailor identifiers to only permit U+00B7 MIDDLE DOT in certain contexts.
[110-C22] Consensus: Issue a new Public Review Issue based on discussion in the meeting of Public Review Issue #96 feedback, including the new Indic properties. [L2/07-043]

[110-C23] Consensus: Create a document proposing that WG2 reference in 10646 the current submission of the Ideographic Variation Database (IVD).

[110-C24] Consensus: Advance Proposed Update Unicode Technical Report #25: Unicode Support for Mathematics to Unicode Technical Report #25: Unicode Support for Mathematics after incorporating input on floors and ceilings from the script subcommittee. L2/07-030]

[110-C25] Consensus: Adopt the proposal on the disposition of Unicode Technical Report #25: Unicode Support for Mathematics math data tables in L2/07-051 in principle.

[110-C26] Consensus: Advance Draft Unicode Technical Report #33: Conformance Model to Unicode Technical Report #33: Conformance Model. [L2/07-045]

[110-M1] Motion: Authorize the Editorial Committee to publish an updated version of Unicode Technical Report #20: Unicode in XML and Other Markup Languages jointly with the W3C. [L2/07-040]

Moved by Asmus Freytag, Seconded by Ken Whistler

6.5 for ( Adobe, Basis, IBM, Microsoft, Sun, Sybase, UCB)
1 against (Google)
2 abstain (JustSystem, Apple)

Motion 110-M1 passes.

[110-C27] Consensus: Withdraw Draft Unicode Technical Standard #40: BOCU-1 MIME-Compatible Unicode Compression from the website, and point to the Unicode Technical Note. [L2/07-059]

[110-C28] Consensus: In response to INCITS IDSP document "Survey on Existing and Needed Identity-Related Standards", the UTC recommends to INCITS that they include consideration of the Unicode Standard (and ISO 10646), as well as Unicode Technical Report #36: Unicode Security Consideration and Unicode Technical Standard #39: Unicode Security Mechanisms. [L2/07-074]

[110-C29] Consensus: The committee is very grateful for the steps taken by TC68/SC7 regarding stabilizing ISO 4217 currency codes to address the requested improvements in "Resolution of US comments on ISO WD 4217", document SC7N094. [L2/07-025]
[110-C30] Consensus: Accept 61 Avestan characters at 10B00..10B3F, with block name Avestan at 10B00..10B3F, and with properties as specified in document L2/07-006, for encoding in a future version of the Unicode standard and a future amendment to 10646: 

@@    10B00    Avestan    10B3F
@    Vowels
U+10B00 AVESTAN LETTER A
U+10B01 AVESTAN LETTER AA
U+10B02 AVESTAN LETTER AO
U+10B03 AVESTAN LETTER AAO
U+10B04 AVESTAN LETTER AN
U+10B05 AVESTAN LETTER AAN
U+10B06 AVESTAN LETTER AE
U+10B07 AVESTAN LETTER AEE
U+10B08 AVESTAN LETTER E
U+10B09 AVESTAN LETTER EE
U+10B0A AVESTAN LETTER O
U+10B0B AVESTAN LETTER OO
U+10B0C AVESTAN LETTER I
U+10B0D AVESTAN LETTER II
U+10B0E AVESTAN LETTER U
U+10B0F AVESTAN LETTER UU
@    Consonants
U+10B10 AVESTAN LETTER KE
U+10B11 AVESTAN LETTER XE
U+10B12 AVESTAN LETTER XYE
U+10B13 AVESTAN LETTER XVE
U+10B14 AVESTAN LETTER GE
U+10B15 AVESTAN LETTER GGE
U+10B16 AVESTAN LETTER GHE
U+10B17 AVESTAN LETTER CE
U+10B18 AVESTAN LETTER JE
U+10B19 AVESTAN LETTER TE
U+10B1A AVESTAN LETTER THE
U+10B1B AVESTAN LETTER DE
U+10B1C AVESTAN LETTER DHE
U+10B1D AVESTAN LETTER TTE
U+10B1E AVESTAN LETTER PE
U+10B1F AVESTAN LETTER FE
U+10B20 AVESTAN LETTER BE
U+10B21 AVESTAN LETTER BHE
U+10B22 AVESTAN LETTER NGE
U+10B23 AVESTAN LETTER NGYE
U+10B24 AVESTAN LETTER NGVE
U+10B25 AVESTAN LETTER NE
U+10B26 AVESTAN LETTER NYE
U+10B27 AVESTAN LETTER NNE
U+10B28 AVESTAN LETTER ME
U+10B29 AVESTAN LETTER HME
U+10B2A AVESTAN LETTER YYE
U+10B2B AVESTAN LETTER YE
U+10B2C AVESTAN LETTER VE
U+10B2D AVESTAN LETTER RE
U+10B2E AVESTAN LETTER LE
U+10B2F AVESTAN LETTER SE
U+10B30 AVESTAN LETTER ZE
U+10B31 AVESTAN LETTER SHE
U+10B32 AVESTAN LETTER ZHE
U+10B33 AVESTAN LETTER SHYE
U+10B34 AVESTAN LETTER SSHE
U+10B35 AVESTAN LETTER HE
@    Punctuation
U+10B39 AVESTAN ABBREVIATION MARK
U+10B3A TINY TWO DOTS OVER ONE DOT PUNCTUATION
U+10B3B SMALL TWO DOTS OVER ONE DOT PUNCTUATION
U+10B3C LARGE TWO DOTS OVER ONE DOT PUNCTUATION
U+10B3D LARGE ONE DOT OVER TWO DOTS PUNCTUATION
U+10B3E LARGE TWO RINGS OVER ONE RING PUNCTUATION
U+10B3F LARGE ONE RING OVER TWO RINGS PUNCTUATION

[110-C31] Consensus: Accept 73 Tay Viet characters at AA80..AADF, with block name Tay Viet at AA80..AADF for encoding in a future version of the standard and a future 10646 amendment. Note that this script is planned to be encoded in visual order. [L2/07-039R]

[110-C32] Consensus: Accept 76 Meitei Mayek characters at 1C80..1CCF; with block name Meitei Mayek at 1C80..1CCF, and with properties as specified in L2/07-005 for encoding in a future version of the standard and in a future amendment of 10646.

[110-C33] Consensus: Approve the new Lanna names as given in L2/07-007, new code point range of 1A20..1AAD, and accept the two new characters U+1A29 LANNA LETTER KHUN HIGH CHA and U+1AAD LANNA SIGN CAANG. 

[110-C34] Consensus: Remove the two Lanna characters with compatibility decompositions: U+1A65 LANNA VOWEL SIGN AM and U+1A66 LANNA VOWEL SIGN TALL AM. [L2/07-007]

[110-C35] Consensus: Accept 20 archaic Sinhala numbers at 0DE7..0DEF and 0DF5..0DFF for encoding in a future version of the standard and future amendment to 10646; all with general category of number-other. [L2/07-002]

[110-C36] Consensus: Accept 88 Bamum characters at A680..A6DF (with name changes to indicate combining marks), with block name Bamum at A680..A6DF, and with properties as specified in document [L2/07-024], for encoding in a future version of the standard and future amendment to 10646.

[110-C37] Consensus: Accept 106 Cyrillic letters, with new blocks Cyrillic Extended B at A640..A67F and Cyrillic Extended C at A8E0..A8FF, for encoding in a future version of the standard: [L2/07-003]
U+0487 COMBINING CYRILLIC POKRYTIE
U+0514 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER LHA
U+0515 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER LHA
U+0516 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER RHA
U+0517 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER RHA
U+0518 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER YAE
U+0519 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER YAE
U+051A CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER QA
U+051B CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER QA
U+051C CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER WE
U+051D CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER WE
U+051E CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER ALEUT KA
U+051F CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER ALEUT KA
U+0520 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER EL WITH MIDDLE HOOK
U+0521 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER EL WITH MIDDLE HOOK
U+0522 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER EN WITH MIDDLE HOOK
U+0523 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER EN WITH MIDDLE HOOK
U+2DF6 COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER A
U+2DF7 COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER IE
U+2DF8 COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER DJERV
U+2DF9 COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER MONOGRAPH UK
U+2DFA COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER YAT
U+2DFB COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER YU
U+2DFC COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER IOTIFIED A
U+2DFD COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER LITTLE YUS
U+2DFE COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER BIG YUS
U+2DFF COMBINING CYRILLIC LETTER IOTIFIED BIG YUS
U+2E3B VERTICAL TILDE
U+A640 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER ZEMLYA
U+A641 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER ZEMLYA
U+A642 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER DZELO
U+A643 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER DZELO
U+A644 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER REVERSED DZE
U+A645 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER REVERSED DZE
U+A646 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER IOTA
U+A647 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER IOTA
U+A648 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER DJERV
U+A649 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER DJERV
U+A64A CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER MONOGRAPH UK
U+A64B CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER MONOGRAPH UK
U+A64C CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER BROAD OMEGA
U+A64D CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER BROAD OMEGA
U+A64E CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER NEUTRAL YER
U+A64F CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER NEUTRAL YER
U+A650 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER YERU WITH BACK YER
U+A651 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER YERU WITH BACK YER
U+A652 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER IOTIFIED YAT
U+A653 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER IOTIFIED YAT
U+A654 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER REVERSED YU
U+A655 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER REVERSED YU
U+A656 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER IOTIFIED A
U+A657 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER IOTIFIED A
U+A658 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER CLOSED LITTLE YUS
U+A659 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER CLOSED LITTLE YUS
U+A65A CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER BLENDED YUS
U+A65B CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER BLENDED YUS
U+A65C CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER IOTIFIED CLOSED LITTLE YUS
U+A65D CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER IOTIFIED CLOSED LITTLE YUS
U+A65E CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER YN
U+A65F CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER YN
U+A662 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER SOFT DE
U+A663 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER SOFT DE
U+A664 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER SOFT EL
U+A665 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER SOFT EL
U+A666 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER SOFT EM
U+A667 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER SOFT EM
U+A668 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER MONOCULAR O
U+A669 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER MONOCULAR O
U+A66A CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER BINOCULAR O
U+A66B CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER BINOCULAR O
U+A66C CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER DOUBLE MONOCULAR O
U+A66D CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER DOUBLE MONOCULAR O
U+A66E CYRILLIC LETTER MULTIOCULAR O
U+A66F COMBINING CYRILLIC VZMET
U+A670 COMBINING CYRILLIC TEN MILLIONS SIGN
U+A671 COMBINING CYRILLIC HUNDRED MILLIONS SIGN
U+A672 COMBINING CYRILLIC THOUSAND MILLIONS SIGN
U+A673 SLAVONIC ASTERISK
U+A67C COMBINING CYRILLIC KAVYKA
U+A67D COMBINING CYRILLIC PAYEROK
U+A67E CYRILLIC KAVYKA
U+A67F CYRILLIC PAYEROK
U+A8E0 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER DWE
U+A8E1 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER DWE
U+A8E2 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER DZWE
U+A8E3 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER DZWE
U+A8E4 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER ZHWE
U+A8E5 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER ZHWE
U+A8E6 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER CCHE
U+A8E7 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER CCHE
U+A8E8 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER DZZE
U+A8E9 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER DZZE
U+A8EA CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER TE WITH MIDDLE HOOK
U+A8EB CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER TE WITH MIDDLE HOOK
U+A8EC CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER TWE
U+A8ED CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER TWE
U+A8EE CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER TSWE
U+A8EF CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER TSWE
U+A8F0 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER TSSE
U+A8F1 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER TSSE
U+A8F2 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER TCHE
U+A8F3 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER TCHE
U+A8F4 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER HWE
U+A8F5 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER HWE
U+A8F6 CYRILLIC CAPITAL LETTER SHWE
U+A8F7 CYRILLIC SMALL LETTER SHWE

[110-C38] Consensus: Accept the name changes to U+2DE0..U+2DF5 as shown on page 17 of document L2/07-003, and change all the glyphs to those shown on page 16 of the same document.

[110-C39] Consensus: Accept 29 new math characters for encoding in a future version of the standard and a future amendment of 10646: [L2/07-011R]
U+2064 INVISIBLE PLUS
U+20F0 COMBINING ASTERISK ABOVE
U+27CC  LONG DIVISION 
U+27EE MATHEMATICAL LEFT FLATTENED PARENTHESIS
U+27EF MATHEMATICAL RIGHT FLATTENED PARENTHESIS
U+2B1B BLACK LARGE SQUARE
U+2B1C WHITE LARGE SQUARE
U+2B1D BLACK VERY SMALL SQUARE
U+2B1E WHITE VERY SMALL SQUARE
U+2B1F BLACK PENTAGON
U+2B24 BLACK LARGE CIRCLE
U+2B25 BLACK MEDIUM DIAMOND
U+2B26 WHITE MEDIUM DIAMOND
U+2B27 BLACK MEDIUM LOZENGE
U+2B28 WHITE MEDIUM LOZENGE
U+2B29 BLACK SMALL DIAMOND
U+2B2A BLACK SMALL LOZENGE
U+2B2B WHITE SMALL LOZENGE
U+2B2C BLACK HORIZONTAL ELLIPSE
U+2B2D WHITE HORIZONTAL ELLIPSE
U+2B2E BLACK VERTICAL ELLIPSE
U+2B2F WHITE VERTICAL ELLIPSE
U+2B45 LEFTWARDS QUADRUPLE ARROW
U+2B46 RIGHTWARDS QUADRUPLE ARROW
U+2B50 WHITE MEDIUM STAR
U+2B51 BLACK SMALL STAR
U+2B52 WHITE SMALL STAR
U+2B53 BLACK RIGHT-POINTING PENTAGON
U+2B54 WHITE RIGHT-POINTING PENTAGON
[110-C40] Consensus: Accept 16 punctuation characters for encoding in a future version of the standard and a future amendment of 10646: [L2/07-004]
U+2E1A HYPHEN WITH DIAERESIS
U+2E1B SWUNG DASH WITH RING ABOVE
U+2E1E SWUNG DASH WITH DOT ABOVE
U+2E1F SWUNG DASH WITH DOT BELOW
U+2E2A TWO DOTS OVER ONE DOT PUNCTUATION
U+2E2C ONE DOT OVER TWO DOTS PUNCTUATION
U+2E2E SQUARED FOUR DOT PUNCTUATION
U+2E2F FIVE DOT MARK
U+2E34 REVERSED QUESTION MARK
U+2E38 RING POINT
U+2E40 LEFT VERTICAL BAR WITH QUILL
U+2E41 RIGHT VERTICAL BAR WITH QUILL
U+2E46 LEFT SIDEWAYS U BRACKET
U+2E47 RIGHT SIDEWAYS U BRACKET
U+2E48 LEFT DOUBLE PARENTHESIS
U+2E49 RIGHT DOUBLE PARENTHESIS

[110-C41] Consensus: Accept 4 half-bracket characters U+2E42 - U+2E45 for encoding in a future version of the standard and future amendment of 10646: [L2/07-004]
U+2E42 TOP LEFT HALF BRACKET
U+2E43 TOP RIGHT HALF BRACKET
U+2E44 BOTTOM LEFT HALF BRACKET
U+2E45 BOTTOM RIGHT HALF BRACKET
[110-C42] Consensus: Accept 7 CJK ideographs at U+9FBC..U+9FC2 for encoding in a future version of the standard. [L2/07-067]
[110-C43] Consensus: Accept U+0972 DEVANAGARI LETTER CHANDRA A for encoding in a future version of the standard. [L2/07-027]
 
[110-C44] Consensus: Make the following changes in properties: [L2/07-071]

U+0374 Alphabetic = F → T
U+0374 GC = Sk → Lm
U+0374, U+0385, U+1FC1, U+1FED..U+1FEF, U+1FFD Script = Greek → Common
U+0387 Wordbreak = Other → MidLetter
U+0387 → Other_ID_Continue

[110-C45] Consensus: There are serious technical problems with the document ISO/IEC CD 19757-7: Document Schema Definition Languages (DSDL) - Part 7: Character Repertoire Description Language. The grapheme cluster description is unnecessarily restrictive and makes it impossible to describe repertoires containing arbitrary combining marks. The UTC also has serious concerns about IANA registrations, and the registration process is unspecified. [L2/06-397, L2/07-052]

[110-C46] Consensus: Text based upon the discussions in the Malayalam ad hoc will be added to the 5.0.1 beta and be part of the public review.