From: Erkki Kolehmainen (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Date: Wed Jun 14 2006 - 02:35:46 CDT
The UCS (ISO/IEC 10646) and Unicode code points are identical, so this
doesn't cause any problem for official referencing.
Since ISO/IEC/JTC1 is not working on enhancing the structure of locale
data (nor should it be, in light of the track record), and the
registration facility that it has provided is both inflexible and
totally insufficient, ignoring the opportunities provided by CLDR is a
major disservice to your user community, nominally justified only by
some unjustifiable formality.
As the editor of CEN Workshop Agreement 14094:2001 on European
Culturally Specific ICT Requirements (which, in spite of being somewhat
outdated, is available for a free download at the CEN website), I wrote:
Note: Thus, each nation and cultural group is strongly urged to:
1. review that their inherent language and other cultural requirements
are covered herein and
2. agree on one or more sets of the default values and submit them for
This is an area, where one cannot depend on the others, except for the
implementation once the homework has been done. Not doing this homework
is tantamount to a public denial of the need for others to respect one's
Sincerely, Erkki I. Kolehmainen
Cristian SecarÄ wrote:
> On Mon, 05 Jun 2006 14:27:07 +0300, Erkki Kolehmainen wrote:
>>>At the end of 2005 and begining of 2006 I had a modest attempt
>>>to get out of sleep an old project for collecting data for a
>>>presumable registration of cultural elements at
>>I don't think that any work should be wasted on this severely
>>outdated project. The one that counts is CLDR.
> In official documents, I cannot make any reference neither to Unicode,
> nor to Unicode codepoints. Likewise, I cannot make any official
> reference to CLDR.
> In official documents I have to make references to ISO/IEC 10646(-1)
> and UCS codepoints. As far as I know, an official reference for
> national cultural elements does not currently exists.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Wed Jun 14 2006 - 02:57:21 CDT