This page is a compilation of formal public feedback received so far. See Feedback for further information on this issue, how to discuss it, and how to provide feedback.
Date/Time: Wed Jun 26 23:14:08 CDT 2019
Name: Eduardo Marin Silva
Report Type: Public Review Issue
Opt Subject: Proposed update for: U-Source Ideographs
In section 1, the sentence that reads: "The actual UTC-source data are found in two additional files:" Should have the "two" word, replaced by "three".
Feedback above this line was reviewed and processed during UTC #160 in July 2019.
Date/Time: Thu Oct 3 01:20:12 CDT 2019
Name: William T. Nelson
Report Type: Public Review Issue
Opt Subject: PRI399 for UAX #45
Comments on §2.1: 1. The status "Comp" is given the meaning, "Encoded as a compatibility ideograph." The intended meaning is unclear for source references UTC-00843 through UTC-00854, which are characters with the unified ideograph property that have been given status "Comp" due to their inclusion in the CJK Compatibility Ideographs block. 2. The meaning for status G should be changed to: "Encoded in Extension G." 3. The use of UTC-00643 ⿴囗辛 as an example of an ideograph with status W is no longer suitable, as its shape is encoded in CJK ext F at U+2D364 𭍤. The following items are drawn from the changeset between USourceData-12.0.0 and USourceData-13.0.0d3: 4. The comments field for UTC-00595 was changed solely to capitalize "Y-variant" and "Z-variant" but the term "y-variant" is not capitalized for UTC-00531. The text of UAX #45 capitalizes like "Z-variant." I suggest using lowercase in all instances to align with UAX #38, which uses "x- or y-variant." 5. The IDS field contents for thirty-three characters (UTC-00915 through UCI-00947) changed from an empty string to a literal representation of the encoded character. Most (but not all) of these have "Comp" status. The change should be explained if intentional, or possibly reverted. 6. On the Unihan list (thread subject: Questionable UTC glyph for U+2BAA2?) it was determined to correct and normalize UTC-00458 𫪢 to ⿰口佞, and to update the stroke count, IDS, and glyph appropriately. The draft U-source data includes the updated stroke count, but the IDS and glyph still need to be updated. 7. UTC-00976 ⿰光夭 was incorrectly changed from status F (U+2D26A 𭉪) to status N. The correct value is status F (U+2D026 𭀦). 8. The Ideographic Variation Indicator (IVI) 〾 appears before an ideograph or IDS, not after. The IDS for the seven Gongche notation characters (UTC-03160 through UTC-03166) should be corrected accordingly. Other comments for USourceData-13.0.0d3: 9. The use of 竹/⺮ as a component in IDS is inconsistent. I suggest using 竹 exclusively to align with kawabata-san's IDS file. 10. Ideographs with status UK-2015 that are confirmed to be in CJK ext G should have their status changed to G. 11. Update status for UK-01969 from UK-2015 to UK-2017. Its current status can be seen on the WS2017 web app: https://hc.jsecs.org/irg/ws2017/app/index.php?find=UK-01969 12. Update RS value for UTC-03018 to 123.4 per IRG52: https://hc.jsecs.org/irg/ws2017/app/index.php?find=UTC-03018 13. UK-02592 ⿵齐贝 was unified with U+2CE73 𬹳 at IRG48. Change code point from U+9F4E to U+2CE73 and status from UK-2015 to E. 14. UTC-03120 ⿱虱䖵 was unified with U+274A2 𧒢 at IRG51. Change status from WS-2017 to B. 15. UTC-03121 ⿰石𠠵 was unified to U+309AE 𰦮 (T13-2F45) at IRG51. Change status from WS-2017 to G. 16. UK-02629 ⿱艹斗 was unified to U+30C29 𰰩 (USAT-90299). Change status from UK-2015 to G. 17. UTC-02971 ⿱少免 has the same shape as U+3779 㝹 (see T6-3E64 or UCV 243) and its status should be changed from N to A. 18. UK-02843 ⿰火篤 is an exact match with U+24498 𤒘. Change code point from U+2C2AF to U+24498 and status from UK-2015 to B. 19. UK-02924 ⿰田朶 is an exact match with U+2DED0 𭻐. Change code point from U+24C67 to U+2DED0 and status from UK-2015 to F. 20. UK-02925 ⿰禾朶 is an exact match with U+2E0C4 𮃄. Change code point from U+2579B to U+2E0C4 and status from UK-2015 to F. 21. UK-02928 ⿱髟朶 is an exact match with U+2EAC4 𮫄. Change code point from U+29B3B to U+2EAC4 and status from UK-2015 to F. 22. UK-02929 ⿰礻朶 unifies with U+2E073 𮁳 (UCV 362). Change code point from U+25668 to U+2E073 and status from UK-2015 to F. 23. UK-02857 ⿰訁嵒 was unified with U+27B0C 𧬌 at IRG47. Change code point from U+2C920 to U+27B0C and status from UK-2015 to B. 24. UK-02918 ⿰訁亜 was unified with U+46E9 䛩 at IRG47. Change status from UK-2015 to A. 25. UK-02930 ⿱木月 was unified with U+2668D 𦚍 at IRG48. Set code point to U+2668D and change status from UK-2015 to B. 26. UTC-03127 ⿰犭⿳⿱⺊乛七巾 was unified to U+247DD 𤟝 at IRG51. Change status from WS-2017 to B or V. 27. UTC-03136 ⿺辶⿱木目 was unified to U+284F3 𨓳 at IRG51. Set code point to U+284F3 and change status from WS-2017 to B or V. 28. IDS for UTC-00406: wrong ⿲糹亓糹, correct ⿲糹亞糹 (per kawabata-san) 29. IDS for UK-01551: currently ⿹⿻一戈首, better as ⿹⿶戈一首 30. IDS for UK-01946: wrong ⿰米, correct ⿰米⿱艹阑 https://hc.jsecs.org/irg/ws2015/app/?find=UK-01946 31. IDS for UK-01852: wrong ⿰忄, correct ⿰忄𬜯 https://hc.jsecs.org/irg/ws2015/app/?find=UK-01852 32. IDS for UTC-03195: wrong ⿱⿳亠 口冖足, correct ⿱⿳亠口冖足 (remove the space character) 33. IDS for UTC-00134 is blank, set to ⿻𣎵一 34. IDS for UTC-00212 is blank, set to ⿻𦫳⿰土匕 35. IDS for UTC-00219 is blank, set to ⿱亡𥘅 36. IDS for UTC-00539 is blank, set to ⿱艹⿻口夫 (per kawabata-san) 37. IDS for UTC-00832 is blank, set to ⿳宀𠀎八 (per kawabata-san) 38. Simplify IDS for UTC-00286 from ⿰宀⿲⿱屮屮⿱人仌⿱屮屮 to ⿱宀⿴茻⿱人仌 39. Simplify IDS for UTC-00287 from ⿰宀⿲⿱屮屮⿱人心⿱屮屮 to ⿱宀⿴茻⿱人心 40. Simplify IDS for UTC-00303 from ⿰⿳艹冖禾⿱囚皿 to ⿰⿱𫇦禾𥁕 41. Simplify IDS for UTC-00485 from ⿰亞⿸厂里 to ⿰亞厘 42. Simplify IDS for UTC-00624 from ⿱宀⿰釆攵 to ⿱宀𫾶 43. Simplify IDS for UTC-00688 from ⿰氵⿱⿵人二心 to ⿰氵𫝹 44. Simplify IDS for UTC-00720 from ⿱⺮⿰⿱士示隶 to ⿱竹隷 45. Simplify IDS for UTC-00738 from ⿰⿱⿱艹罒⿱冖日色 to ⿰𣊔色 46. Simplify IDS for UTC-00740 from ⿳艹冖音 to ⿱𫇦音 47. Simplify IDS for UTC-00765 from ⿰阝⿱白土 to ⿰阝𭎊 48. Simplify IDS for UTC-00843 from ⿱⿰文隹又 to ⿱𮥷又 49. Simplify IDS for UK-01586 from ⿱⿰知于日 to ⿱𥎿日 50. Simplify IDS for UK-01572 from ⿸虍⿱且又 to ⿸虍𫨶 51. Simplify IDS for UK-01628 from ⿰糹⿱火⿰𠂈又 to ⿰糹⿱火𠬞 (per IRG49) 52. Simplify IDS for UK-02960 from ⿳雲⿲雲龍雲⿰龍龍 to ⿳雲⿲雲龍雲龖 53. Simplify IDS for UCI-02969 from ⿰山⿱㞌⿰㞌㞌 to ⿰山⿱㞌𡥷