ISO/IEC JTC1/SC2/WG3 N511

Title:   Result of the ad-hoc meeting on proposed second CD 2375
Source:  Michael Everson
Date:    2000-09-19

The issues outlined in N498 were resolved as follows:

1. The recommendation given on page 4 was accepted.

2. The recommendations given on page 7 were accepted but the text will be
made clearer. It was noted in the discussion that disagreement between the
JAC and SA on content of mapping is not grounds for appeal; national bodies
reviewing the registration may recommend correction of errors, but they do
not appeal either.

3. The recommendation given on page 8 were accepted.

4. The first recommendation given on page 10 was accepted; the second was not.

5. The recommendations given on page 12 was accepted. Annex C will be
retained. It is the intention that this standard will be comprehensive
enough that a separate Practice of the Registration Authority document will
not be necessary. A specific note about glyph changes being accepted by the
Owner of Origin will be added.

6. The recommendations given on page 13 were accepted. It would be
inappropriate to specify a format for mapping tables, so long as they are
clear. Clause 13 will be updated to show that the SA must provide clear
mapping tables in electronic format.

7. The recommendations given on page 14 were not accepted. It is the
responsibility of an SA to update its mapping(s).

8. The recommendation given on page 15 was accepted.

9. We believe all the RA concerns have been met, but they will have to
review the CD when it is available.