Universal Multiple-Octet Coded Character Set
(UCS)
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC
2/WG 2 N2104r
Date: 1999-09-21
Source: |
WG 2 meeting 37, Copenhagen, Denmark; 1999-09-13--16 |
Title: |
Resolutions of WG 2 meeting 37 |
Action: |
For approval by SC 2 and for information to WG 2 and
WG 3 |
Status: |
Adopted at meeting 36 of WG 2 |
Distribution: |
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 2 and WG 2. |
Canada, China,
Denmark, Finland, Germany, Ireland, Japan, Netherlands, Norway, Poland,
Romania, Sweden, UK, USA, AFII (Liaison), CEN/TC304 (Liaison), the Unicode
Consortium (Liaison), and Lithuania (Guest) were represented when the following
resolutions were adopted. 35 delegates representing 14 national bodies, 3 liaison organizations and 1 guest, were present at different
times during the meeting (see attached attendance list).
(Note:
Resolution M37.23 which was missed during the meeting was added after the
meeting ended.)
RESOLUTION M37.1 (TCOR 3):
Unanimous
WG 2 accepts the comment from Korea on draft TCOR-3 and text of Annex xx on Hangul names in document N2077, and instructs its project editor to prepare a disposition of comments and the final text of TCOR-3 and forward it to SC2 secretariat for further processing.
RESOLUTION M37.2 (FPDAM-15 on Kang
Xi and CJK radicals):
Unanimous
WG 2 accepts the revised disposition of comments on FPDAM-15 ballot in document N2079r, and instructs its project editor to prepare the final text of FDAM-15 with assistance from the contributing editor, and forward these documents to SC 2 secretariat for further processing with unchanged target dates.
RESOLUTION M37.3 (FPDAM-28 on
Ideographic description characters):
Unanimous
WG 2 accepts the revised disposition of comments on FPDAM-28 ballot in document N2079r, and instructs its project editor to prepare the final text of FDAM-28 with assistance from the contributing editor, and forward these documents to SC 2 secretariat for further processing with unchanged target dates.
RESOLUTION M37.4 (PDAM-29 on
Mongolian script):
Unanimous
WG 2 accepts the revised disposition of comments on FPDAM-29
ballot in document N2079r, and instructs its project editor to prepare the
final text of FDAM-29 with assistance from the contributing editor, and forward
these documents to SC 2 secretariat for further processing with unchanged target
dates.
RESOLUTION M37.5 (PDAM-30 on
Additional Latin and other characters):
Unanimous
WG 2 accepts the revised disposition of comments on FPDAM-30 ballot in document N2079r, and instructs its project editor to prepare the final text of FDAM-30 with assistance from the contributing editor, and forward these documents to SC 2 secretariat for further processing with unchanged target dates.
RESOLUTION M37.6 (PDAM-31 on
Tibetan extensions):
Unanimous
WG 2 accepts the revised disposition of comments on FPDAM-31 ballot in document N2079r, and instructs its project editor to prepare the final text of FDAM-31 with assistance from the contributing editor, and forward these documents to SC 2 secretariat for further processing with unchanged target dates.
RESOLUTION M37.7 (Defect report on
Thai character names):
Unanimous
With reference to documents N2026, N2035 and N2036, WG2 accepts its project editor's response to add annotations on the character names as the proper solution, and instructs its editor to process it further.
RESOLUTION M37.8 (Next edition of
10646-1):
Unanimous
WG2 instructs its editor to prepare a revised text of document N2005 (textual part of the next edition of 10646-1) incorporating changes arising from:
a) Amendment 15
b) Amendment 28
c) Amendment 29
d) Amendment 30
e) Amendment 31
f) Technical Corrigendum 3 (see resolution M37.1 above)
g) Responses to comments on N2005 in documents N2082, and N2108 (amended by discussion at this meeting)
h) Updated list of sources of characters in Annex M (based on documents N2084, N2106, and changes to N2106 based on discussion at this meeting)
i) Annotations to Thai character names (see resolution M37.7 above)
and forward the revised text to SC2 secretariat for circulation to national bodies and liaison organizations for information, by 1999-11-01.
WG2 further instructs its project editor to prepare the camera ready copy of the second edition of 10646-1 consisting of the above revised text, the final code charts for non-CJK ideographs from AFII and the final code charts for CJK ideographs from the IRG, and submit it to ITTF by 1999-11-01.
RESOLUTION M37.9 (Mathematical
alphanumeric symbols):
Unanimous
WG2 accepts the proposal for 991 (subject to verification of this number) new mathematical alphanumeric symbols in document N2086, for inclusion in 10646-2, in the range D400 -- D7FF in Plane 1. The project editor is to select the appropriate character names and block name in the preparation of the text for inclusion in part 2.
RESOLUTION M37.10 (CJK unified
ideograph extension B):
Unanimous
WG2 accepts the proposal for 42,807 CJK unified ideographs of extension B in document N2105 from the IRG, for encoding in plane 2 of 10646-2, in the range 0100 -- ABFF. The WG2 notes that the IRG contributing editor has provided the code charts organized as 16 rows by 8 columns. WG2 further accepts dropping of the word "unified" from the name of plane 2. The project editor is to select the appropriate names for the characters and the block name in the preparation of the text for inclusion in part 2.
RESOLUTION M37.11 (2nd WD of
10646-2):
Unanimous
WG2 accepts the disposition of comments in document N2087r on the 2nd WD of 10646-2 and instructs its project editor to prepare the text for CD 10646-2 with assistance from the contributing editors, including the Mathematical Alphanumeric Symbols (see resolution M37.9 above) and the CJK unified ideographs extension B (see resolution M37.10 above) in the CD. WG2 further instructs its project editor to submit the CD document to SC2 secretariat for a CD ballot with unchanged target dates.
RESOLUTION M37.12 (Feedback to
D.P.R of Korea):
Unanimous
With reference to the NP in document N2056 to amend the Korean encoding of Amendment 5, WG2 instructs its convener to inform SC2 to respond to the Committee for Standardization of the D.P.R. of Korea:
a) that WG2 cannot support this NP because any reordering of the standardized Korean Hangul characters would harm existing implementations that are using the standard including its Amendment 5
b) that existing standardized character names cannot be changed because character names are normative in the standard and changing them would harm existing users of these standardized character names
c) invite them to make concrete proposals to add any missing characters following the existing WG2 Procedures and Guidelines document (JTC1/SC2/WG2 N2002), and the conventions for naming of characters in the standard, for future consideration by WG2, and,
d) invite
them to participate in the IRG regarding any Hanja character requirements they
may have
and,
e) draw their attention to FCD-3 of ISO/IEC 14651 -- international ordering under ballot in SC22.
RESOLUTION M37.13 (Feedback to
Romania):
Unanimous
With reference to document N2117 (letter from Romania to SC 2 requesting changes to Annex P of 10646-1), WG2 instructs its convener to inform SC2 that the request of Romania cannot be considered at this time, and to invite the Romanian national body to resubmit it for consideration after the relevant 8859 part has become a standard.
RESOLUTION M37.14 (Response to
report on ETSI meeting ):
Unanimous
WG2 invites Mr. Karl Ivar Larsson to prepare an appropriate response to document N2118 on harmonizing ETSI GSM SMS standard with 10646 in consultation with the convener and forward it to ETSI.
RESOLUTION M37.15 (Liaison request
from W3C I18N WG):
Unanimous
WG2 accepts the offer to establish the Category C liaison from W3C I18N WG in document N2081, and appoints its convener Mr. Mike Ksar as the liaison representative from WG2. WG2 requests SC2 to process this liaison and the nomination.
RESOLUTION M37.16 (CJK
compatibility ideographs from JIS):
Unanimous
WG2 requests IRG to review document N2095 on CJK compatibility Ideographs from Japan, and provide their input to WG2 before meeting 38 of WG2, in the context of IRG resolution M13.8 in document N2111.
RESOLUTION M37.17 (Japanese NB
concerns to JTC 1 on SC 2 program of work):
Germany and Sweden Abstained
WG2 takes note of the comments in document N2062 (SC2 N3336, JTC1 N5826) regarding the issue of when to use NP versus subdivision process for new amendments to 10646. WG2 endorses the recommendations from SC2 ad hoc group established at the SC2 meeting no. 9 in Fukuoka, Japan. Further, WG2 accepts and endorses the recommendations in contribution N2049 (SC2 N3341), and instructs its convener to forward document N2049 along with a summary of the recommendations to SC 2 secretariat for forwarding to JTC 1. WG2 also encourages its experts to get support from their national JTC 1 committees of the recommendations contained in document N2049.
RESOLUTION M37.18 (Future
meetings):
Unanimous
WG 2 confirms the following future meeting schedule:
-
Meeting 38: 21--24 March 2000, Beijing, China
-
Meeting 39: 11-15 September 2000, Greece (US as fall back)
(along with SC2 and SC2/WG3 meetings)
-
Meeting 40: March 2001 - US (subject to confirmation)
WG 2 accepts and confirms the following IRG future meeting schedule:
- IRG 14: 6--10 December 1999 in Singapore
- IRG 15: 15--19 May 2000 in Taiwan
- IRG 16: November 2000 in Korea
RESOLUTION M37.19 (Appreciation to
project editor and contributors)
By acclamation
WG2 thanks its project editor and all contributing editors on the successful completion of Amendments 17 (Han vertical extension A), Amendment 18 (Miscellaneous symbols including EURO) and Amendment 21 (Sinhala script).
RESOLUTION M37.20 (Appreciation to
IRG)
By acclamation
WG2 thanks the members of IRG, the IRG editor and its
rapporteur for their timely and valuable contribution on CJK-related items for
inclusion in the second edition of 10646-1 and in the preparation of the first
CD of 10646-2.
RESOLUTION M37.21 (Appreciation to
AFII)
By acclamation
WG2 thanks AFII, for their excellent support in preparing
and printing the camera ready copy of the non-Han code tables for the next
edition of 10646-1.
RESOLUTION M37.22 (Appreciation to
the host):
By acclamation
WG 2 thanks its hosts,
Dansk Standard, DKUUG, Kommunedata, and their staff for hosting the
meeting, for providing excellent secretarial and administrative support, and
for their kind hospitality.
RESOLUTION M37.23 (Appreciation to
DKUUG for web services):
(Added after the meeting ended)
WG 2 thanks DKUUG, in particular Mr. Keld Simonsen, for its
continued support of the web site for WG 2 document distribution and the e-mail
server.
ISO/IEC JTC 1/ SC
2 /WG 2
Meeting 37, Copenhagen, Denmark
1999-09-13—16
Attendance List
The following 35
delegates representing 14 national bodies, 3 liaison organizations and 1 guest
attended the meeting.
Name |
Representing |
Affiliation |
Alain La Bonté |
Canada |
Direction du soutien au déploiement de l'inforoute gouvernmentale, Gouvernement du Québec |
V. S. (Uma) Umamaheswaran |
Canada, |
IBM Canada |
Chen Zhuang |
China |
Chinese Electronic Standardization Institute |
Lobsang Tokme |
China |
Interpretation Bureau of Tibet Autonomous Region |
Quejingzhabu |
China |
Inner Mongolia University |
Shama Layi |
China |
Southwest National Institute, Nansiduan |
Woshur Slamu |
China |
Xinjiang University |
Yasin Imin |
China |
National Language and Character Committee |
Zhang Zhoucai |
China, IRG Rapporteur |
CCID |
Michael Y. Ksar |
Convener |
Hewlett-Packard Company |
Bent Barnholdt |
Denmark |
Independent |
Birger Jacobsen |
Denmark |
BITS |
Keld Drube |
Denmark |
Dansk Standard |
Myanne Olesen |
Denmark |
DKUUG |
Sven Thygesen |
Denmark |
Kommunedata |
Erkki Kolehmainen |
Finland, CEN TC304 |
Tieke |
Marc Küster |
Germany |
Universitنt Tübingen |
Paul Dettmer |
Germany |
Independent |
Vladas Tumasonis |
Guest - Lithuania |
Vilnius University |
Michael Everson |
Ireland |
Everson Gunn Teoranta |
Satoshi Yamamoto |
Japan |
Hitachi, Ltd. |
Shun Ishizaki |
Japan |
Keio University |
Takayuki Sato |
Japan |
Independent |
Johan van Wingen |
Netherlands |
Independent |
Keld Simonsen |
Norway |
Rationel Almen Planlوgning |
Elżbieta Broma-Wrzesień |
Poland |
Telekomunikacja Polska S.A. |
Alexandrina Stătescu |
Romania |
Romtelecom |
Mihaela Anghelescu |
Romania |
Romanian Standards Association |
Karl Ivar Larsson |
Sweden |
Independent Consultant |
Asmus Freytag |
The Unicode Consortium, AFII |
ASMUS, Inc. |
Bruce Paterson |
U.K.; Editor Part 1 |
Independent |
Arnold Winkler |
U.S.A. |
Unisys Corporation |
Hideki Hiura |
U.S.A. |
SunSoft, Inc. |
Michel Suignard |
U.S.A.; Editor Part 2 |
Microsoft |